World Metro Database

#	City  >	< City aka  >	< Country  >	< Continent  >	< System  >	< Stations  >	< Stations*  >	< Lines  >	<  km/stn*  >	< km/line  >	< stns/line  >	< Passengers  >	< Pass/km  >	< Pass.year  >	< Tracks  >	< Driverless  >	< Rubber-tyred  >	< Driverless since  >	< PSDs  >	< Aircon trains  >	< Walk-through
1	Dalian		China	Asia	Metro	12	12	1	4.08	49.0	12.0				right
2	San Francisco		USA	America	BART	43	43	5	3.88	33.4	8.6	100 mio.	599,000	2007	right					yes
3	Dubai		United Arab Emirates	Asia	Metro	11	11	1	3.61	39.7	11.0				right	metro		2009	metro, monorail	yes	yes
4	Mumbai	Bombay	India	Asia	Suburban Railway	73	73	5	2.34	34.2	14.6
5	Hong Kong		China	Asia	MTR	95	82	9	2.29	20.9	10.6	1309 mio.	6,959,000	2008	left	Disneyland Resort Line	SI, WI lines, planned	2005	all underground stations	yes	yes
6	Valparaiso		Chile	America	Metro	20	20	1	2.15	43.0	20.0				right
7	Atlanta		USA	America	MARTA	39	38	2	2.08	39.6	19.5	34 mio.	429,000	1994	right					yes
8	Moscow		Russia	Europe	Metro	180	144	12	2.07	24.9	15.0	2573 mio.	8,611,000	2008	right
9	Saint Petersburg	Leningrad	Russia	Europe	Metro	63	55	5	2.00	22.0	12.6	832 mio.	7,550,000	2007	right				windowless steel doors in ten stations
10	Washington		USA	America	Metrorail	90	86	5	1.99	34.2	18.0	215 mio.	1,256,000	2008	right					yes
11	Porto Alegre		Brazil	America	Metro	17	17	1	1.99	33.8	17.0				right
12	Saint Louis		USA	America	Metrolink	37	37	2	1.98	36.7	18.5				right
13	Los Angeles		USA	America	Metro Rail	30	30	3	1.98	19.8	10.0	45 mio.	759,000	2008	right					yes
14	Tianjin		China	Asia	Metro	37	37	2	1.95	36.0	18.5	15 mio.	208,000	1993	right				platform gate doors	yes
15	Guangzhou	Canton	China	Asia	Metro	88	79	5	1.88	29.7	17.6	601 mio.	4,047,000	2008	right					yes	yes
16	Seattle		USA	America	Light Rail	12	12	1	1.85	22.2	12.0				right					yes
17	Brasilia		Brazil	America	Metro	23	23	1	1.83	42.0	23.0	16 mio.	381,000	2002	right
18	Beijing		China	Asia	Subway	147	125	9	1.82	25.3	16.3	1200 mio.	5,274,000	2008	right				PGDs on underground stations of line 5, PSDs on lines 8, 10	recently	all lines
19	Baltimore		USA	America	Metro Subway	14	14	1	1.75	24.5	14.0	14 mio.	571,000	2008	right					yes
20	Singapore		Singapore	Asia	MRT	76	69	4	1.72	29.7	19.0	571 mio.	4,802,000	2007	left	North-East MTR line and 3 rubber-tyred LRT lines	LRT lines	2003		yes	yes
21	Cleveland		USA	America	Rapid Transit	18	18	1	1.72	31.0	18.0	6 mio.	194,000	2008	right
22	Shanghai		China	Asia	Metro	230	194	10	1.72	33.4	23.0	1122 mio.	3,359,000	2008	right				newer line 4 stations and refitted line 1 stations	yes
23	Lima		Peru	America	Tren Urbano	6	6	1	1.67	10.0	6.0
24	Volgograd	Stalingrad	Russia	Europe	Metro	2	2	1	1.65	3.3	2.0
25	Miami		USA	America	Metrorail	22	22	1	1.64	36.0	22.0	19 mio.	528,000	2008	right	downtown people mover, rubber-tyred	Downtown people mover	1986		yes
26	Chennai	Madras	India	Asia	MRTS	17	17	1	1.59	27.0	17.0
27	Sydney		Australia	Oceania	Cityrail	14	14	3	1.58	7.4	4.7				left					yes
28	Bucharest		Romania	Europe	Metro	50	43	4	1.57	16.9	12.5	111 mio.	1,640,000	1999	right
29	Baku		Azerbaijan	Asia	Metro	22	21	2	1.56	16.4	11.0	176 mio.	5,356,000	2007	right
30	Oporto	Porto	Portugal	Europe	Metro	15	14	2	1.55	10.9	7.5				right					yes	yes
31	Newcastle		United Kingdom	Europe	Tyne & Wear Metro	61	50	2	1.53	38.3	30.5	38 mio.	497,000	2006	left
32	London		United Kingdom	Europe	Underground	268	268	11	1.52	37.1	24.4	1197 mio.	2,934,000	2007	left	Docklands Light Rail		1987	Jubilee Line extension		yes (DLR)
33	Istanbul		Turkey	Europe	Metro	10	10	1	1.50	15.0	10.0	68 mio.	4,533,000	2008	right
34	Kryvyi Rih	Krivoy Rog	Ukraine	Europe	Metrotram	12	12	1	1.50	18.0	12.0
35	Pyongyang		North Korea	Asia	Metro	16	15	2	1.50	11.3	8.0	35 mio.	1,556,000	2006
36	Tokyo		Japan	Asia	Metro	290	205	13	1.49	23.4	22.3	3174 mio.	10,424,000	2008	left	Yurikamome Waterfront line, rubber-tyred	Yurikamome line	1995	Marunouchi, Mita, Namboku, Yurikamome lines	yes	yes
37	Belo Horizonte		Brazil	America	Metro	19	19	1	1.48	28.1	19.0				right
38	Vancouver		Canada	America	Sky Train	49	47	3	1.48	23.2	16.3	74 mio.	1,065,000	2008	right	Skytrain, LIM technology, currently the world's longest automated system		1986		yes	yes
39	Recife		Brazil	America	Metro	30	28	2	1.42	19.9	15.0				right
40	Kharkov	Kharkiv	Ukraine	Europe	Metro	28	25	3	1.41	11.8	9.3	278 mio.	7,875,000	2007	right
41	Stuttgart		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	19	17	2	1.41	12.0	9.5				right						yes
42	Tashkent		Uzbekistan	Asia	Metro	29	26	3	1.39	12.1	9.7	71 mio.	1,961,000	2007	right
43	Kiev	Kyiv	Ukraine	Europe	Metro	46	43	3	1.39	19.9	15.3	642 mio.	10,736,000	2007	right
44	Kazan		Russia	Europe	Metro	6	6	1	1.38	8.3	6.0	7 mio.	843,000	2007	right
45	Mexico City		Mexico	America	Metro	175	147	11	1.37	18.3	15.9	1460 mio.	7,238,000	2008	right		yes
46	Nanjing		China	Asia	Metro	16	16	1	1.36	21.7	16.0	102 mio.	4,700,000	2008	right
47	Osaka		Japan	Asia	Subway	133	104	9	1.33	15.3	14.8	860 mio.	6,241,000	2008	left	Nanko Port Town Line, rubber-tyred	Nanko Port Town Line	1981	all stations on the Nanko Port Town Line		yes
48	Caracas		Venezuela	America	Metro	50	46	5	1.32	12.1	10.0	510 mio.	8,430,000	2008						yes
49	Sofia		Bulgaria	Europe	Metro	14	14	1	1.29	18.0	14.0	51 mio.	2,833,000	2008	right
50	Yokohama		Japan	Asia	Subway	48	45	3	1.28	19.2	16.0	198 mio.	3,438,000	2008	left	Kanazawa Seaside line, LRT, rubber-tyred	Kanazawa Seaside LRT	1989	Kanazawa Seaside LRT line		yes
51	Kobe		Japan	Asia	Subway	26	24	2	1.28	15.3	13.0	121 mio.	3,954,000	2008	left	Port Liner and Rokko Liner, rubber-tyred	Port Liner and Rokko Liner	1981	Port Liner and Rokko Liner		yes
52	Rotterdam		Netherlands	Europe	Metro	38	37	2	1.27	23.5	19.0	85 mio.	1,809,000	2006	right
53	Minsk		Belarus	Europe	Metro	25	24	2	1.26	15.1	12.5	262 mio.	8,647,000	2007	right
54	Tbilisi		Georgia	Asia	Metro	22	21	2	1.25	13.1	11.0	92 mio.	3,498,000	2007	right
55	Cairo		Egypt	Africa	Metro	55	53	2	1.24	32.8	27.5	700 mio.	10,687,000	2002	left					5 stns
56	Rio de Janeiro		Brazil	America	Metro	34	34	2	1.24	21.0	17.0	135 mio.	3,214,000	2006	right					yes
57	Helsinki		Finland	Europe	Metro	17	17	1	1.24	21.0	17.0	58 mio.	2,762,000	2008	right						yes
58	Shenyang	Mukden	China	Asia	Metro	18	18	1	1.23	22.2	18.0				right
59	Madrid		Spain	Europe	Metro	281	231	13	1.23	21.8	21.6	686 mio.	2,415,000	2008	left					yes	yes
60	Yekaterinburg	Ekaterinburg	Russia	Asia	Metro	7	7	1	1.21	8.5	7.0	46 mio.	5,412,000	2007	right
61	Yerevan	Erevan	Armenia	Asia	Metro	10	10	1	1.21	12.1	10.0	17 mio.	1,405,000	2007	right
62	Nizhny Novgorod	Gorky	Russia	Europe	Metro	14	13	2	1.19	7.8	7.0	33 mio.	2,129,000	2007	right
63	Novosibirsk		Russia	Asia	Metro	13	12	2	1.19	7.2	6.5	70 mio.	4,895,000	2007	right
64	Edmonton		Canada	America	Light Rail	11	11	1	1.19	13.1	11.0				right
65	Delhi		India	Asia	Metro	83	81	3	1.19	32.1	27.7	310 mio.	3,224,000	2008	left					yes
66	Kaohsiung		Taiwan	Asia	MRT	37	36	2	1.19	21.4	18.5	30 mio.	703,000	2008					MRT
67	Dnepropetrovsk	Dnipropetrovsk	Ukraine	Europe	Metro	6	6	1	1.18	7.1	6.0	11 mio.	1,549,000	2007
68	Manila		Philippines	Asia	MRT	42	39	3	1.17	15.2	14.0	346 mio.	7,571,000	2008						yes	yes
69	Bangkok		Thailand	Asia	Skytrain, MRT	44	40	3	1.16	15.4	14.7	206 mio.	4,449,000	2007	left	Green line		1999	Green line, Blue line	yes
70	Chicago		USA	America	"L"	151	144	8	1.15	20.8	18.9	198 mio.	1,193,000	2008	right					yes
71	Medellin	Medellín	Colombia	America	Metro	26	25	2	1.15	14.4	13.0	155 mio.	5,382,000	2008
72	Jacksonville		USA	America	Skyway	6	6	1	1.15	6.9	6.0				right	downtown monorail people mover		1989
73	Izmir		Turkey	Asia	Metro	10	10	1	1.15	11.5	10.0	30 mio.	2,609,000	2005
74	Shenzhen		China	Asia	Metro	23	22	2	1.15	12.6	11.5	73 mio.	2,885,000	2005	right					yes	yes
75	Tehran		Iran	Asia	Metro	47	44	3	1.15	16.8	15.7	353 mio.	6,990,000	2007						yes
76	Kuala Lumpur		Malaysia	Asia		60	56	3	1.14	21.3	20.0	109 mio.	1,703,000	2008	left	LRT		1996	KLIA line to airport, Kelana Jaya line's underground stations	yes
77	Naples		Italy	Europe	Metro	30	28	3	1.14	10.6	10.0	29 mio.	912,000	2006	left
78	Samara		Russia	Europe	Metro	9	9	1	1.13	10.2	9.0	12 mio.	1,176,000	2007	right
79	Taipei		Taiwan	Asia	MRT	85	80	8	1.13	11.3	10.6	450 mio.	4,967,000	2008	right	Muzha line, VAL	yes	1996	Muzha line VAL MRT	yes	yes
80	Hamburg		Germany	Europe	U-Bahn	97	89	3	1.13	33.6	32.3	184 mio.	1,827,000	2007	right
81	Sao Paulo		Brazil	America	Metro	58	55	4	1.11	15.3	14.5	684 mio.	11,158,000	2008	right					lines 4, 5, and regional rail
82	Duisburg		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	13	13	2	1.10	7.2	6.5				right						yes
83	Prague		Czech Republic	Europe	Metro	57	54	3	1.09	19.7	19.0	597 mio.	10,102,000	2008	right						yes
84	Hanover		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	21	17	3	1.09	6.2	7.0				right						yes
85	Nagoya		Japan	Asia	Subway	93	82	4	1.09	22.3	23.3	427 mio.	4,798,000	2008	left	Tobu Kyuryo maglev line		2005	Tobu Kyuryo maglev line		yes
86	Maracaibo		Venezuela	America	Metro	6	6	1	1.08	6.5	6.0									yes
87	Athens		Greece	Europe	Metro	52	48	3	1.08	17.3	17.3	325 mio.	6,250,000	2007	right					yes	yes
88	Chongqing		China	Asia	Monorail	18	18	1	1.08	19.5	18.0				right				The three underground stations (Daping, Linjiangmen, and Jiaochangkou) have PSDs	yes	yes
89	Busan		South Korea	Asia	Subway	92	88	3	1.08	31.7	30.7	257 mio.	2,705,000	2008	right
90	Warsaw		Poland	Europe	Metro	21	21	1	1.08	22.6	21.0	114 mio.	5,044,000	2007	right
91	Kolkata	Calcutta	India	Asia	Metro Railway	21	21	1	1.08	22.6	21.0	100 mio.	4,425,000	2000	right
92	San Juan		Puerto Rico	America	Tren Urbano	16	16	1	1.08	17.2	16.0	9 mio.	523,000	2008
93	Bilbao		Spain	Europe	Metro	38	38	2	1.07	20.3	19.0	86 mio.	2,118,000	2008	left					yes	yes
94	Changchun		China	Asia		16	16	1	1.06	17.0	16.0				right
95	Stockholm		Sweden	Europe	Tunnelbana	104	100	3	1.06	35.2	34.7	303 mio.	2,867,000	2007	left
96	Ankara		Turkey	Asia	Metro	23	22	2	1.05	11.6	11.5	113 mio.	4,892,000	2007	right	metro line		1997
97	Buffalo		USA	America	Metro Rail	8	8	1	1.04	8.4	8.0				right
98	Sapporo		Japan	Asia	Subway	49	46	3	1.04	16.0	16.3	209 mio.	4,354,000	2008	left						yes
99	Toronto		Canada	America	Subway	74	69	4	1.03	17.8	18.5	278 mio.	3,899,000	2006	right					yes
100	Daejeon	Taejon	South Korea	Asia	Subway	22	22	1	1.03	22.6	22.0	29 mio.	1,283,000	2008
101	Wuhan		China	Asia	Metro	10	10	1	1.02	10.2	10.0				right
102	Montreal	Montréal	Canada	America	Metro	73	68	4	1.02	17.3	18.3	219 mio.	3,165,000	2006	right		yes
103	Incheon	Inchon	South Korea	Asia	Subway	29	29	1	1.02	29.5	29.0	73 mio.	2,475,000	2008
104	Poznan		Poland	Europe		6	6	1	1.02	6.1	6.0
105	Monterrey		Mexico	America	Metro	32	31	2	1.02	15.8	16.0				right		yes
106	Kyoto		Japan	Asia	Subway	32	31	2	1.01	15.6	16.0	126 mio.	4,026,000	2008	left				Tozai line		yes
107	Boston		USA	America	The T	66	60	3	1.01	20.2	22.0	145 mio.	2,397,000	2007	right					yes
108	Gwangju		South Korea	Asia	Subway	20	20	1	1.01	20.1	20.0	17 mio.	846,000	2008
109	Adana		Turkey	Asia		8	8	1	1.00	8.0	8.0
110	Philadelphia		USA	America	Subway	66	62	3	1.00	20.7	22.0	67 mio.	1,081,000	2008	right					yes
111	Amsterdam		Netherlands	Europe	Metro	33	33	4	0.99	8.2	8.3	91 mio.	2,783,000	2002	right
112	Munich		Germany	Europe	U-Bahn	100	94	6	0.98	15.4	16.7	349 mio.	3,773,000	2008	right						yes
113	Daegu	Taegu	South Korea	Asia	Subway	56	55	2	0.98	27.0	28.0	110 mio.	2,041,000	2008
114	Bursa		Turkey	Asia		23	23	1	0.98	22.5	23.0
115	Santiago	Santiago de Chile	Chile	America	Metro	93	86	5	0.97	16.6	18.6	642 mio.	7,735,000	2008	right		yes
116	Seoul		South Korea	Asia	Subway	348	298	10	0.96	28.7	34.8	2048 mio.	7,138,000	2008	right				lines 2 and 9, planned for all lines by 2010	yes	yes
117	Copenhagen		Denmark	Europe	Metro	22	22	2	0.95	10.5	11.0	37 mio.	1,762,000	2002	right	all metro lines		2002	all underground stations	all metro and S-Tog trains	yes
118	The Hague		Netherlands	Europe	RandstadRail	30	30	3	0.93	9.3	10.0				right
119	Palma de Mallorca		Spain	Europe	Metro	9	9	1	0.92	8.3	9.0
120	Santo Domingo		Dominican Republic	America	Metro	16	16	1	0.91	14.5	16.0
121	Lisbon		Portugal	Europe	Metro	52	46	4	0.89	10.3	13.0	180 mio.	4,390,000	2007	left						yes
122	Milan		Italy	Europe	Metro	88	84	3	0.89	24.9	29.3	328 mio.	4,397,000	2007	right					yes	yes
123	Valencia		Venezuela	America	Metro	7	7	1	0.89	6.2	7.0	18 mio.	2,903,000	2008
124	Las Vegas		USA	America	Monorail	7	7	1	0.89	6.2	7.0				right	monorail		2004
125	Cologne		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	51	51	15	0.88	3.0	3.4				right					new light rail trains only	yes
126	Fukuoka		Japan	Asia	Subway	35	34	3	0.88	9.9	11.7	124 mio.	4,161,000	2007	left						yes
127	Hiroshima		Japan	Asia	Monorail	21	21	1	0.88	18.4	21.0	18 mio.	978,000	2005	left
128	Charleroi		Belgium	Europe		20	20	4	0.88	4.4	5.0
129	New York	New York City	USA	America	Subway	468	422	27	0.87	13.6	17.3	1624 mio.	4,413,000	2008	right				planned for new Second Avenue Line	yes
130	Sendai		Japan	Asia	Subway	17	17	1	0.87	14.8	17.0	58 mio.	3,919,000	2008	left						yes
131	Barcelona		Spain	Europe	Metro	152	128	10	0.86	11.1	15.2	378 mio.	3,421,000	2008	right				under construction on lines 5, 11, planned for lines 9, 10	yes	yes
132	Chiba		Japan	Asia	Monorail	18	18	2	0.86	7.8	9.0				left
133	Oslo		Norway	Europe	T-Bane	72	72	5	0.86	12.4	14.4	64 mio.	1,032,000	2005	right						yes
134	Valencia		Spain	Europe	Metro	38	37	3	0.86	10.6	12.7
135	Guadalajara		Mexico	America	Metro	29	28	2	0.86	12.0	14.5				right
136	Seville	Sevilla	Spain	Europe	Metro	21	21	1	0.86	18.0	21.0								Line 1
137	Naha		Japan	Asia	Monorail	15	15	1	0.85	12.8	15.0				left
138	Berlin		Germany	Europe	U-Bahn	195	173	10	0.85	14.7	19.5	447 mio.	3,033,000	2008	right						yes
139	Tama		Japan	Asia	Monorail	19	19	1	0.84	16.0	19.0				left						yes
140	Vienna		Austria	Europe	U-Bahn	96	84	5	0.83	14.0	19.2	498 mio.	7,135,000	2008	right					yes	yes
141	Budapest		Hungary	Europe	Metro	42	40	3	0.83	11.0	14.0	297 mio.	9,000,000	2008	right
142	Kamakura		Japan	Asia	Monorail	8	8	1	0.82	6.6	8.0				left
143	Rome		Italy	Europe	Metro	49	48	2	0.81	19.5	24.5	331 mio.	8,487,000	2008	left					yes	yes
144	Marseille		France	Europe	Metro	26	24	2	0.80	9.6	13.0	58 mio.	3,005,000	2004	right		yes
145	Bochum		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	29	27	2	0.80	10.8	14.5				right
146	Dortmund		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	37	37	3	0.80	9.8	12.3				right						yes
147	Lyon		France	Europe	Metro	43	39	4	0.79	7.7	10.8	182 mio.	5,928,000	2004	left	line D/Maggaly, rubber-tyred, no PSDs	yes	1991
148	Nuremberg		Germany	Europe	U-Bahn	46	44	3	0.79	11.5	15.3	92 mio.	2,659,000	1997	right	lines U2, U3, no PSDs, sharing tracks with driver-operated trains		2008			yes
149	Frankfurt		Germany	Europe	U-Bahn	31	27	3	0.76	6.8	10.3				right						yes
150	Lille		France	Europe	Metro	62	60	2	0.76	22.8	31.0	74 mio.	1,626,000	2004	right	VAL	yes	1983	VAL, all stations		yes
151	Mulheim	Mülheim	Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	13	12	2	0.75	4.5	6.5				right
152	Bonn		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	12	12	1	0.75	9.0	12.0				right
153	Essen		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	27	27	3	0.75	6.7	9.0				right						yes
154	Toulouse		France	Europe	Metro	38	37	2	0.74	13.8	19.0	42 mio.	1,527,000	2004	right	VAL	yes	1993	VAL		yes
155	Genoa		Italy	Europe	Metro	7	7	1	0.74	5.2	7.0				right						yes
156	Bielefeld		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	7	7	4	0.74	1.3	1.8				right
157	Paris		France	Europe	Metro	380	300	16	0.71	13.3	23.8	1473 mio.	6,915,000	2008	right (metro), left (RER)	line 14/Météor, rubber-tyred	lines 1, 4, 6, 11, 14	1998	all stations on line 14, under construction on line 13		lines 1, 14
158	Buenos Aires		Argentina	America	Subte	76	68	6	0.70	7.9	12.7	280 mio.	5,895,000	2008	left						yes
159	Glasgow		United Kingdom	Europe	Subway	15	15	1	0.69	10.4	15.0	15 mio.	1,442,000	2008	left
160	Antwerp		Belgium	Europe	Premetro	11	11	2	0.69	3.8	5.5
161	Turin		Italy	Europe	Metro	14	14	1	0.69	9.6	14.0				right	VAL	yes	2006	VAL	yes	yes
162	Duesseldorf	Düsseldorf	Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	14	14	2	0.68	4.8	7.0				right						yes
163	Kitakyushu		Japan	Asia	Monorail	13	13	1	0.68	8.8	13.0				left						yes
164	Wuppertal		Germany	Europe	Schwebebahn	20	20	1	0.67	13.3	20.0				right
165	Catania		Italy	Europe	Metro	6	6	1	0.63	3.8	6.0				right
166	Gelsenkirchen		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	9	9	1	0.61	5.5	9.0				right
167	Rennes		France	Europe	Metro	15	15	1	0.60	9.0	15.0	23 mio.	2,556,000	2004	right	VAL	yes	2002	VAL		yes
168	Newark		USA	America	Subway	4	4	1	0.55	2.2	4.0				right
169	Brussels		Belgium	Europe	Metro	61	59	3	0.55	10.7	20.3	136 mio.	4,224,000	2008	right					line 1B
170	Lausanne		Switzerland	Europe	Metro	29	28	2	0.49	6.8	14.5					line m2	line m2	2008			yes
171	Pittsburgh		USA	America	The T	3	3	1	0.48	1.5	3.0				right
172	Rouen		France	Europe	Metro	5	5	1	0.44	2.2	5.0
173	Perugia		Italy	Europe	Minimetro	7	7	1	0.43	3.0	7.0
174	Detroit		USA	America	People Mover	13	13	1	0.37	4.8	13.0				right	downtown people mover, LIM technology		1987		yes
175	Ludwigshafen		Germany	Europe	Stadtbahn	11	11	0	0.36						right
176	Haifa		Israel	Asia	Carmelit	6	6	1	0.29	1.8	6.0

Feedback